There have only been two times in history where the price of platinum has been less than gold. Right now is only the second time this has happened.
Platinum has “always” sold for more than gold because the supply of platinum is only a fraction of that of gold. This scarcity creates a higher valuation for platinum.
I think that we have this incredible anomaly for two reasons.
Gold has become a monetary instrument again. This has increased the demand for gold beyond the previous levels of demand. In fact, the demand for gold has become less rational than I have seen since probably 1980.
Platinum, on the other hand, is relatively suffering because of the weak global economy. Platinum is both a precious metal and an industrial metal. The industrial side of platinum is showing weak demand. And its value as a precious metal is being overwhelmed by the demand for gold.
I think that the advent of the big gold ETFs, like GLD, has led to irrational demand for gold that is pushing gold up too far in relation to platinum.
This irrational situation will eventually end and rationality will prevail.
I want to buy platinum and sell gold.
The platinum contract is for 50 ounces while gold is for 100 ounces. So you need to do two platinum contracts for every one gold contract.
Here is another analysis by Andy Waldock:
(October 26, 2011) The next time someone asks you if you’d rather have an ounce of gold or, an ounce of platinum you might want to think about your answer. Platinum’s relative value to gold has plummeted over the last two months. In fact platinum is currently $140 less per ounce than gold. This is the lowest value I could come up with using the entire history of the platinum and gold futures markets.
There have basically been three periods when platinum traded at a discount to gold. All three of these periods were characterized by fearful economies. The first period from ’80- ’83 saw platinum bottom at $131 less than gold. We also had a total of 6 quarters of negative GDP growth during this period. The second period was ’91-’93. We only had two quarters of negative GDP during this period. We are currently in our third period of platinum’s discount to gold and we’ve had four consecutive quarters of negative GDP finally ending in the second quarter of 2009.
The three periods of platinum’s discount have averaged more than 15 months in duration. The historical sell off in this market fits right in with the volatility we are growing used to. Therefore, we must focus on the underlying dynamics to predict the next range of volatility.
All three of these periods have been defined by recession, declining consumer confidence and household deleveraging. Perhaps the clearest measure of this is through the Federal Reserve Board’s Household Debt Service Ratio data. This measures how much debt American’s carry relative to their disposable income.
Declining sentiment can be measured by the amount of debt we carry relative to our expectations for economic growth.
Debt is the first thing that is shed as the economy sours and we may be nearing the bottom of this debt shedding cycle. Prior to the personal debt explosion of the 2000’s, American’s debt to disposable income tended to trade in a range of 10.5% to 12%. While this may seem like a tight range, consider the effects of your own personal debt varying by nearly 15% and you’ll get an idea of what that range feels like to the average American consumer. The debt boom peaked in Q3 of 2007 at nearly 14% of disposable household income. Currently, we have pulled back to just over 11%. This puts us near our historical trough levels. However, it is important to remember that trends tend to overshoot on the downside just as much as they do on the upside. Therefore, I would expect to set a new record trough in terms of household deleveraging some time in 2013.
This is one of the rare opportunities to watch a truly macro economic trade made in the commodity markets. The industrial demand for platinum is fueled by the government’s mandated shift to ultra low emission vehicles (ULEV’s) as well as the global growth of the auto industry, which is heavily based on platinum use in catalytic convertors. Furthermore, the speculative nature of the gold market’s rally will eventually fall of its own weight when some degree of certainty manifests itself in the global markets.
The average ratio of gold to platinum is more than 1.5 times. This ratio is obviously negative at the moment as we are currently at an historical low. I expect resolution of the European banking crisis and a resumption of normal business operations to quickly snap this market back to a normal pricing structure. Once this happens, the market should continue to build a base as individual populations work their own debt issues out. Finally, I expect to look back in time and be grateful to have seen this once every 10 years opportunity well in advance of the market’s turn.
October 26, 2011
Commodity & Derivative Advisors, LLC
P.O. Box 484 Sandusky OH